"Prayer How to do nothing and still think you're helping" pic
One of the most peculiar things that religious people do is pray. The reasons I find it peculiar is that (1) There is no evidence that prayer works and abundant evidence that it doesn't work, (2) Praying to an omniscient being seems pointless, and (3) Praying is often done in situations where some other action might actually help.
The reason I say there's plenty of evidence prayer doesn't work is... well, any honest religious person will tell you that not all of their prayers come true. If they pray that a sick loved one pulls through and she dies, what does that mean? Does it mean God doesn't care? Does it mean God isn't all powerful? Does it mean God doesn't exist? The religious people will usually excuse the failure of prayer because the death was part of God's mysterious plan. But if their sick loved one pulls through then they get to attribute it to prayer! Hallelujah! So the logical problem with the prayer theory is that it's not falsifiable; no matter the outcome you still praise the power of prayer.
Now if God does exist and He is all knowing, as most Christians and Muslims believe, then why would we need to pray to "Him"? God already knows your loved one is sick, and knows you don't want her to die, so why do you even need to ask? If God is good as most Christians / Muslims believe, then God wouldn't want an innocent person to die. So why must the sick person's relatives pray for a miracle cure? If God cures all the good people with people who love them, why does He even let them get sick in the first place? Oh right, it's all part of His mysterious plan.
I digress, but my point is that the idea of verbally asking God for favors implies that God is not God. On forums I often see threads about my ____ is sick or injured and pleading for other members to pray for them. So let me get this straight- My sick auntie is going to die unless I get a couple hundred strangers to beg God to let her live? Did God invent chain letters? What kind of sick sadistic fuck forces his own creations to beg for their lives? It's as if God is holding my poor auntie hostage... If I don't get him his ransom of 200 Hail Mary's then he's going to start sending me her fingers one by one to let me know he's fucking serious.
Of course, if you believe in Heaven, then arguably you shouldn't even be sad if your loved one dies. After all, they get to go to eternal paradise which beats the hell out of lying sick in bed on crummy old planet Earth.
All in all, praying amounts to doing nothing. And granted, there are instances, such as when a friend is sick, when there is absolutely nothing you can do. But what about all of the times where a person could do something to help but instead just prays? Instead of praying for the poor, how about donating to a charity or volunteering for a soup kitchen?
Wake Up Call
Rants from a long time atheist
Tuesday, December 28, 2010
Pascal's Wager
The argument I hear in favor of believing in God more often than any other is known as Pascal's Wager. In a nut shell, the argument goes that everyone should believe in God because not believing could result in going to HELL. But if it turns out that god/s does not actually exist, then there's no afterlife so nothing bad happens... (except perhaps that you wasted countless Sundays listening to boring church sermons and blew a lot of money in collection plates that could have been used for necessities or given to a charity, rather than paying for your priest's new beachfront condo.).
But my question is: if you only choose to believe in a god "just in case" Hell awaits unbelievers, is that really faith or is it just lip service? It's not surprising that the most popular argument in favor of believing is not evidence of god's existence but rather a scare tactic.
I don't believe in god because I have seen no solid evidence of a god's existence. But I certainly like to think that if I am wrong and a god/s exist that s/he would actually commend me for being true to my instincts and logic rather than blindly following an organized religion that invokes scare tactics to pressure people into joining a specific church... If the truth was staring you in the face, there'd be no need for faith. Faith is, by definition, blind.
For even in the unlikely event that a god exists, how can humans truly know anything about what god wants? It baffles me how very religious people can always act so sure that their specific religion is the correct one... there are many different religions in the world and countless religions were very popular at one time which are virtually extinct now... so how can anyone be 100% sure their religion is the correct one?
Of course, instead of following an organized religion, one could simply be a Deist... But does a Deist really live their life any differently than an Atheist / Agnostic would? I try to be a "good" person by inflicting as little harm as possible on other people, animals, and the planet... Not because I am afraid of Hell or want to score Karma points, but because I have empathy. There's plenty of suffering in the world and I don't want to cause any more. When I help others I feel good and it is its own reward- so I've no need of a Heaven either.
The religious people who are only "good" because they want to go to Heaven rather than Hell are not necessarily moral; they're just well-behaved. What if there is a God but s/he punishes the "faithful" who only behaved good out of concern for the afterlife rather than for "goodness's sake"? Ironic, huh?
But my question is: if you only choose to believe in a god "just in case" Hell awaits unbelievers, is that really faith or is it just lip service? It's not surprising that the most popular argument in favor of believing is not evidence of god's existence but rather a scare tactic.
I don't believe in god because I have seen no solid evidence of a god's existence. But I certainly like to think that if I am wrong and a god/s exist that s/he would actually commend me for being true to my instincts and logic rather than blindly following an organized religion that invokes scare tactics to pressure people into joining a specific church... If the truth was staring you in the face, there'd be no need for faith. Faith is, by definition, blind.
For even in the unlikely event that a god exists, how can humans truly know anything about what god wants? It baffles me how very religious people can always act so sure that their specific religion is the correct one... there are many different religions in the world and countless religions were very popular at one time which are virtually extinct now... so how can anyone be 100% sure their religion is the correct one?
Of course, instead of following an organized religion, one could simply be a Deist... But does a Deist really live their life any differently than an Atheist / Agnostic would? I try to be a "good" person by inflicting as little harm as possible on other people, animals, and the planet... Not because I am afraid of Hell or want to score Karma points, but because I have empathy. There's plenty of suffering in the world and I don't want to cause any more. When I help others I feel good and it is its own reward- so I've no need of a Heaven either.
The religious people who are only "good" because they want to go to Heaven rather than Hell are not necessarily moral; they're just well-behaved. What if there is a God but s/he punishes the "faithful" who only behaved good out of concern for the afterlife rather than for "goodness's sake"? Ironic, huh?
If religion is the opiate of the masses...
Everyone has heard the paraphrasing of Karl Marx, that "Religion is the opiate of the masses". However, the full quote is a little more complex than that:
But the gist of Marx's message is that organized religion is bad because keeps the oppressed people from overcoming their oppression... So for instance, the poor people become content with poverty with the promise of a rich, luxurious afterlife. I tend to agree with this but it brings to mind the question: if religion is the "opiate of the masses", does that make atheism their smelling salt?
I honestly do not have a problem with people believing in whatever God/s they choose. If it gives them some kind of solace to believe in a fairy tale, then I guess their ignorance is bliss. Even though I am pretty sure I am right, I acknowledge the possibility that I am wrong.
My beef is with the organized religions that teach followers to not be content with their own faith, but to proselytize all unbelievers. Because when someone tries to change the beliefs of others it inevitably leads to them controlling the behavior of others. That is precisely why I have no desire to "convert" theists to Atheism. Atheism is not a religion and I abhor it being treated as such. I have met quite a few other atheists and frankly the atheists who seek to convert everyone to Atheism are giving us a bad name. Secular Humanism is a bunch of bullshit. I do not need or want any kind of any kind organization or dogma to follow. I am entirely capable of using my conscience, empathy, logic, and reason to decide what actions are ethical or not. The efforts of some atheists to make Atheism more like religion are counter-productive at best and potentially dangerous at worst; Because organized religion is inherently problematic, with or without a supernatural figurehead!
I have a problem with anyone who wants to make me follow laws based not on principles of protecting "life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness", but rather on their religious dogma. If religious people can learn to appreciate the necessity of absolute separation of church and state, then I see no reason why atheists and theists cannot live together in relative peace.
Religious distress is at the same time the expression of real distress and the protest against real distress. Religion is the sigh of the oppressed creature, the heart of a heartless world, just as it is the spirit of a spiritless situation. It is the opium of the people. The abolition of religion as the illusory happiness of the people is required for their real happiness. The demand to give up the illusion about its condition is the demand to give up a condition which needs illusions.
But the gist of Marx's message is that organized religion is bad because keeps the oppressed people from overcoming their oppression... So for instance, the poor people become content with poverty with the promise of a rich, luxurious afterlife. I tend to agree with this but it brings to mind the question: if religion is the "opiate of the masses", does that make atheism their smelling salt?
I honestly do not have a problem with people believing in whatever God/s they choose. If it gives them some kind of solace to believe in a fairy tale, then I guess their ignorance is bliss. Even though I am pretty sure I am right, I acknowledge the possibility that I am wrong.
My beef is with the organized religions that teach followers to not be content with their own faith, but to proselytize all unbelievers. Because when someone tries to change the beliefs of others it inevitably leads to them controlling the behavior of others. That is precisely why I have no desire to "convert" theists to Atheism. Atheism is not a religion and I abhor it being treated as such. I have met quite a few other atheists and frankly the atheists who seek to convert everyone to Atheism are giving us a bad name. Secular Humanism is a bunch of bullshit. I do not need or want any kind of any kind organization or dogma to follow. I am entirely capable of using my conscience, empathy, logic, and reason to decide what actions are ethical or not. The efforts of some atheists to make Atheism more like religion are counter-productive at best and potentially dangerous at worst; Because organized religion is inherently problematic, with or without a supernatural figurehead!
I have a problem with anyone who wants to make me follow laws based not on principles of protecting "life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness", but rather on their religious dogma. If religious people can learn to appreciate the necessity of absolute separation of church and state, then I see no reason why atheists and theists cannot live together in relative peace.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)